What happens if I lose my card? November 21, 2022 22:32 Updated The subscriber can call PayForward Member Services at 844-944-9273 to get a replacement card. This number can be found on www.BlueRewardsSC.com. Related articles I’ve registered for a Blue Rewards account. When will I get my card? Will I get a new Blue Rewards card to use in 2023? Can I add my own dollars to my Blue Rewards card since it is a reloadable Visa prepaid card? Will a new card be issued after completion of each activity? How does the Blue Rewards program work?